Hi folks,
I know my opinion doesn't carry any weight since im just an apprentice samurai but sharing it won't hurt anyone
Since the question was "Would you raid 1 extra day?" I voted "No" since most weeks I don't have enough free time to raid 4 times.
But if you ask me "Should there be 4 raids up in the calendar?" the answer would be "Hell YEA!"
From my point of view:
Pros:
- there are people who can be available for 4 raids
- people like me can also occasionally be available for 4 raids
- in case I can't come on one of the standard days (Wed/Thu/Sun) I can swap it for the 4th instead of being available for only 2
- the guild as a whole will have more progress time
Cons:
- if there are many who can do 3 out of 4 always doing all 4 could require more raiders
- having more raiders can lead to less discipline and less feeling of a "group/family"
- having the option to choose has a chance of badly aligning the attendance of key people
To sum it up - i love the idea of having 4 raids up in the calendar even though I won't be available for them all.
I like Getslaven's idea to review/adjust the signups on e.g. Wednesday so that everyone knows which days there will be a raid for the week in advance.
Cheers,
Zuriel